Posted by david on November 9th, 2008
I’ve been thinking recently about the situation of people who live in poverty, particularly given the current recession. Several related issues in the press have factored into my thoughts. One issue is the share of taxes that the wealthy should bear. Another issue, at least in Maryland where I work, is whether the state should allow slot machines, ostensibly to raise money for education, and whether it amounts to a regressive tax.
These issues lead me to think about tithing and whether it’s fair to ask all people, regardless of income level, to pay the same percentage of their income to the Church. I have always believed tithing to be a true commandment of God and have always believed in the reality of the blessings promised in the scriptures.
But these recent political issues lead me to think more about the temporal blessings of faithful Church activity and obedience to all the laws of God including tithing. After reviewing these blessings, I’ve come to the conclusion that on a temporal level alone, obedience to these laws which necessarily includes tithing is not only fair but may end up being a greater benefit to those in lower income levels.
I’ll list below many of the temporal benefits offered to faithful Saints by the Church. These are difficult to quantify, so my conclusion is largely subjective. Nevertheless, if one were able to add up the value of the temporal blessings gained by faithful Church activity of Saints living in lower income levels, it would likely outweigh the cost of tithing paid by those Saints.
- Word of Wisdom savings. This may be the easiest to quantify on a personal level. Those who join the Church and give up coffee, tea, alcohol, and tobacco can easily add up the savings. In Bankrate.com’s list of Top 10 money drains, coffee, cigarettes, and alcohol made up the top three. According to the National Coffee Association, the average price for brewed coffee is $1.38. There are roughly 260 weekdays per year, so buying one coffee every weekday morning costs almost $360 per year. However, coffee drinkers averaged 3.2 cups per day. That works out to $1,611 per year! Cigarette smokers pay even more. According to Bankrate.com, the average price for a pack of cigarettes is $4.54. Smoking one pack a day costs $1,660 a year at that price. The cost of alcohol can top both coffee and tobacco. While the price of drinks varies by type and location, assuming an average of $5 per beer (with tip), buying two beers per day adds up to $3,650 per year. Figure twice that for two mixed drinks a day at the local bar. Clearly, for people in a lower tax bracket, giving up these three vices can easily save more than what they would pay in tithing.
- Church welfare assistance. Many wards in the U.S. have members who may need assistance from time to time due to job loss, economic crisis, divorce, or death. The value of groceries provided by the local bishop’s storehouse can easily add up into the thousands over the period during which the member received assistance. During this period, members are encouraged to pay tithing even if their income is meager.
- Perpetual Education Fund loans. In many parts of the world where a higher percentage of Saints live in poorer circumstances than do Saints in the U.S., the PEF offers a step up to a better life financially. While these are loans, not grants, and must be paid back, the long-term value of these loans can easily exceed the value of the tithing paid by those who use them. Note that PEF loans for school are only available to faithful members of the Church and may be the only opportunity many will have to obtain a better education.
- Job assistance. Wards and stakes have employment specialists who can assist members in finding work if unemployed or better work if underemployed.
- Prophetic warnings and counsel. Perhaps the greatest temporal benefit of faithful Church activity is the counsel provided by living prophets. When a prophet warns that we must be prepared, following that counsel can lead to inestimable financial blessings. This also applies to the counsel to become more self-reliant, to live within our means, to avoid all but the most necessary debt, to pay off debt as soon as possible, and to get a good education.
Paying tithing is a critical component of this blessings of Church membership. In some cases, the benefits are only available to full-tithe payers. In other cases, one doesn’t have to pay tithing to benefit, but the faithful payment of tithes will help one to have the guidance of the spirit necessary to fully enjoy the blessings offered.
In addition, while financial wealth is not promised, the Lord truly does prosper his people by opening the windows of heaven. Faithful members of the Church sometimes lose their jobs, incur terrible debt from medical problems, lose their homes to fire and other disasters, or suffer from economic downturns. However, paying tithing may help some to avoid such difficult circumstances and will certainly help members to better cope with these challenges should they arise. President Joseph F. Smith said:
“… one of the best ways that I know of to pay my obligations to my brother, my neighbor, or business associate, is for me first to pay my obligations to the Lord. I can pay more of my debts to my neighbors, if I have contracted them, after I have met my honest obligations with the Lord, than I can by neglecting the latter; and you can do the same. If you desire to prosper, and to be free men and women and a free people, first meet your just obligations to God, and then meet your obligations to your fellowmen. Bishop Hunter used to put the matter in these words: “Brethren, pay your tithing and be blessed”, and that is just what I mean.” (Conference Report, Apr. 1903, p. 2)
More recently, Elder James E. Faust said:
“One of the greatest lessons I have learned during my lifetime about doing the best things in the worst times is that people who pay their tithing in both difficult times and good times get along better. They simply have fewer problems; there are fewer family problems and fewer financial problems. Their outlook is more positive, their ability to do and function is increased, and they prosper spiritually as well as temporally.†(“Doing the Best Things in the Worst Times,†Ensign, Aug. 1984, 41)
My conclusion, then, is that paying a full tithe is fair to ask of everyone, rich and poor alike. All are blessed in innumerable ways, but more especially the poor relative to their current condition temporally. The law of tithing has been a great blessing to me and my family throughout my life during periods of poverty and prosperity and continues to bless my life. I know it is a true principle of faith and power.
20 Comments »